Episode 11 of “Beheneko: The Elf-Girl’s Cat is Secretly an S-Ranked Monster!” sees Aria and Tama venturing deeper into the mysteries surrounding Lumines and the encroaching demonic threat, but is the show losing its way? This episode, titled “The Philosopher’s Stone & the Secret of Lumines,” focuses on setting the stage for a larger conflict while introducing new characters and potential betrayals.
Journey to Lumines: A Fortress Transformed
The episode showcases Lumines, Arya’s birthplace, significantly improved with large white walls. This contrasts sharply with the previous episodes’ portrayal of it as a carefree, wooden town, highlighting the village’s growth into a fortified settlement [6]. The group’s arrival introduces them to Fiona, who guides them, along with the village leader. The leader discusses gathering elves from other villages, including the formation of an Amazon unit [6].
New Faces, Hidden Agendas?
A key element introduced in Episode 11 is Gonia, a dark elf who immediately raises suspicion. The leader tasks her with discovering the Philosopher’s Stone [6]. Despite Stella’s claims of Gonia’s power, she’s swiftly defeated by Alicia, raising questions about her true strength and loyalty [6]. The episode hints at Gonia being a potential traitor, seeking the Philosopher’s Stone for her own purposes [6]. However, some viewers feel her immediate capture and removal lacked fanfare, diminishing any potential payoff [9].
Fan Service and Mother-Daughter Bonding
The episode includes a bath scene between Aria and her mother, which some viewers consider a fan service element. However, opinions are divided, with some finding it difficult to discern as true fan service due to the limited exposure [6]. This scene also serves to develop the relationship between Aria and her mother, showcasing the mother’s growth and determination to protect Lumines alongside her daughter [6, 12]. This conversation, while nice, may not resonate deeply with viewers because it relies on the nonsensical premise of the mother randomly acquiring a super powerful skill [9].
The Philosopher’s Stone and Looming Threats
The quest for the Philosopher’s Stone takes center stage as the group ventures into a dungeon to locate it [6]. They encounter Arya’s mother, who now possesses the ability to generate shockwaves [6]. They discover the Philosopher’s Stone is located behind a tree in an underground area [6]. Later, the demon attacks a knight [6].
Tama’s Role and Lost Manga Content
Tama, the reincarnated knight-turned-cat, continues to be a central figure, though some viewers feel the anime is missing key character development for him. One such instance is chapter 52 of the manga, which is not in the anime. The chapter shows Tama wondering how to get back to his Holy Beast form after the battle, and shows him training in the dungeon [6].
Criticism and Overall Impression
Despite the plot developments, some viewers express disappointment with the episode and the series overall. Criticisms include a generic plot, a lack of genuine danger, and a failure to invest viewers in the emotional stakes [9]. Some find the bridging of comedic moments with heartfelt emotions ineffective, resulting in a disjointed viewing experience [9]. Others critique the animation, particularly the CGI monsters, although some notice improved facial details [6].
