“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” continues its enthralling narrative with Episode 4, delving deeper into the mysteries surrounding the Werewolf Forest and the enigmatic Emerald Witch, Sieglinde Sullivan. This episode, titled “His Butler, Serving,” masterfully balances the dark fantasy elements with character development, particularly focusing on Ciel’s fractured mental state and Sebastian’s unwavering dedication to his master, even amidst unusual circumstances.
A Butler’s Bargain: Sebastian’s New Role
The episode opens with Sebastian fulfilling his agreement with Sieglinde to serve as her butler while she works to cure Ciel of the amnesia and trauma he suffered after their encounter in the cursed forest. True to his word, Sebastian immediately begins attending to Sieglinde’s needs, starting with serving her Ceylon tea in bed . This sets the stage for a series of scenes where Sebastian imparts his knowledge of British etiquette and manners to the young witch .
Etiquette Lessons and Wardrobe Changes
Sieglinde, eager to learn, embraces Sebastian’s lessons on proper table manners, silverware usage, and dining etiquette . She also expresses a desire to dress in the style of the “foreigners,” Ciel and his entourage . When Hilde, Sieglinde’s caretaker, objects due to a lack of suitable clothing and concerns about bad luck, Sebastian swiftly improvises, sewing a stylish outfit for Sieglinde from a bed comforter . This showcases Sebastian’s resourcefulness and adaptability, even in the most unconventional situations.
Wolfram’s Discomfort and Village Mistrust
However, Sebastian’s presence as Sieglinde’s butler isn’t met with universal approval. Wolfram, Sieglinde’s loyal bodyguard and former butler, feels displaced by Sebastian’s arrival . The village women also express their mistrust of outsiders, blaming Wolfram for allowing Ciel and his household to stay in Wolfsschlucht . They warn him that he will regret his decision, highlighting the deep-seated suspicion and isolation of the village .
Ciel’s Fractured Mind: Trauma and Dependence
While Sebastian navigates his new role, Ciel remains confined to his bed, grappling with the lingering effects of the werewolf’s curse. He is terrified and refuses to leave his room, highlighting the profound trauma he has endured .
Finnian’s Care: A Bond of Shared Experience
Ciel only feels comfortable around Finnian, the Phantomhive gardener, allowing him to tend to his needs . Finnian tries to coax Ciel into eating and going outside, but Ciel’s fear is overwhelming . This emphasizes the unique bond between Ciel and Finnian, who shares a past of trauma and experimentation .
A Glimpse into Finnian’s Past
The episode offers a glimpse into Finnian’s past, revealing that he was once a human experiment known as Subject #12 . Ciel named him Finnian after the hero Fionn mac Cumhaill from Irish folklore, giving him a new identity and purpose . This act of kindness deeply resonates with Finnian, who is determined to protect Ciel, viewing him as the one who saved him from a life of destruction .
Sebastian’s Discovery: A Tearful Revelation
As Sebastian settles into his role, he continues to investigate the mysteries surrounding Wolfsschlucht. His investigation leads him to a secret cellar, where he makes a discovery that brings tears to his eyes . The exact nature of this discovery is not revealed, but it clearly has a profound impact on him, hinting at deeper secrets and potential dangers lurking within the village .
Victorian Medicine: Bacon for Sore Throats?
In a lighter moment, Sebastian attempts to use a Victorian medical remedy to soothe Ciel’s throat, suggesting wrapping bacon around it . However, a humorous analysis reveals that this particular remedy may not have been a common practice in Victorian medicine, showcasing the anime’s occasional playful inaccuracies .
Themes and Analysis
Episode 4 of the “Emerald Witch Arc” explores several key themes:
Trauma and Recovery
Ciel’s struggle with trauma is a central focus, highlighting the lasting impact of his past experiences. His dependence on Finnian underscores the importance of trust and connection in the healing process .
Duty and Sacrifice
Sebastian’s willingness to serve Sieglinde demonstrates his unwavering dedication to Ciel and his commitment to fulfilling his duties, even when faced with uncomfortable or unconventional circumstances .
Outsiders and Mistrust
The villagers’ suspicion of outsiders reflects the insular nature of Wolfsschlucht and the deep-seated fear of the unknown . This theme explores the challenges of bridging cultural divides and overcoming prejudice.
Hidden Secrets and Dark Pasts
The episode hints at deeper secrets and dark pasts within Wolfsschlucht, suggesting that the truth behind the werewolf curse and the Emerald Witch’s power is more complex than it seems .
Overall Impression
“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” Episode 4 is a compelling installment that effectively advances the plot while delving into the characters’ emotional complexities. The episode’s balance of dark fantasy elements, humor, and character development makes it a standout in the series . The episode leaves viewers eager to uncover the secrets of Wolfsschlucht and witness Ciel’s journey towards recovery.
