Episode 5 of Anne with an E, titled “Tightly Knotted to a Similar String,” delivers a potent mix of humor and emotion as Anne navigates the complexities of growing up in Avonlea. From a heated spelling bee competition with Gilbert Blythe to the mortifying arrival of her first period and an accidental intoxication incident with Diana, Anne faces a series of challenges that test her resilience and shape her understanding of the world.
Academic Rivalry and “Womanly Flowering Time”
The episode opens with Anne participating in a spelling bee at school, where she finds herself in a fierce competition against Gilbert Blythe. This scene highlights their academic rivalry, a recurring theme in their relationship. Anne emerges victorious, but soon after, she experiences stomach pains and discovers she has started her period.
Confused and frightened, Anne believes she is dying and attempts to clean the bloodstained sheets. Marilla discovers her and explains that she is now a woman. Anne is initially distraught, lamenting that she is not ready for womanhood. Marilla’s handling of the situation showcases her growing acceptance and empowerment as a parent.
Despite her distress, Anne insists on going to school, determined to keep up with her studies, particularly against Gilbert. She confides in Jane and the other girls about her experience, learning that Diana has had her period for a year already. Anne’s day is filled with anxiety, fearing an “accident,” and she considers it the worst day ever. Adding to her woes, she and Gilbert have a spat after school.
Matthew’s Affection and a New Dress
Meanwhile, Matthew notices Anne’s discomfort and longing for pretty clothes. He decides to buy her a dress with puff sleeves, a fashionable item Anne desires. Overcoming his social awkwardness, Matthew ventures into town. He initially enters the dress shop but quickly retreats, overwhelmed. Instead, he seeks help from Jeannie, an old acquaintance, confiding in her about Anne and his wish to buy her a dress. This encounter reveals Matthew’s past crush on Jeannie and provides insight into his character. He eventually sends Jerry to pick up the dress and gives him a button for Jeannie. Anne is overjoyed with the dress, eagerly anticipating wearing it to church.
Raspberry Cordial Debacle
To cheer Anne up, Marilla agrees to let her invite Diana over for tea. Anne, wanting to make a good impression, prepares meticulously. However, a mishap occurs when Anne accidentally serves Diana red currant wine instead of raspberry cordial. Diana becomes intoxicated, leading to a confrontation with her strict mother, Mrs. Barry.
Mrs. Barry, disapproving of Anne’s influence, forbids Diana from associating with her. This devastates both girls, who pledge eternal friendship and exchange locks of hair in remembrance. Marilla attempts to reason with Mrs. Barry, but her efforts are unsuccessful. At school, Diana is moved to sit next to Ruby Gillis, further emphasizing the separation.
Themes and Significance
“Tightly Knotted to a Similar String” explores several significant themes:
- Coming of Age: The episode tackles the often-unmentionable topic of menstruation, portraying Anne’s initial fear and confusion and Marilla’s supportive response.
- Friendship: The bond between Anne and Diana is tested by Mrs. Barry’s disapproval, highlighting the importance of female friendship and the pain of separation.
- Social Class and Acceptance: Anne’s lower social standing and orphan background contribute to Mrs. Barry’s prejudice, emphasizing the challenges Anne faces in gaining acceptance within the community.
- Matthew’s Quiet Love: Matthew’s actions throughout the episode demonstrate his growing affection for Anne. He pays attention to her desires and makes a grand gesture by buying her the dress she longs for.
- Academic Competition: The episode subtly emphasizes the academic rivalry between Anne and Gilbert which many find to be an endearing part of their early relationship.
Cast
The episode features the main cast members:
- Amybeth McNulty as Anne Shirley
- Geraldine James as Marilla Cuthbert
- R.H. Thomson as Matthew Cuthbert
- Dalila Bela as Diana Barry
- Lucas Jade Zumann as Gilbert Blythe
- Corrine Koslo as Rachel Lynde
- Helen Johns as Mrs. Eliza Barry
- Kyla Matthews as Ruby Gillis
- Lia Pappas-Kemps as Jane Andrews
Reception
“Tightly Knotted to a Similar String” was generally well-received, with reviewers praising its handling of sensitive topics, character development, and emotional depth. The episode is considered a standout for its iconic moments and exploration of themes relevant to both the time period and contemporary audiences.
