The “Emerald Witch Arc” of Black Butler has captivated viewers with its blend of mystery, gothic horror, and character development. Episode 12, in particular, serves as a pivotal point, tying together loose ends and setting the stage for future conflicts. This article delves into the key events, themes, and implications of this episode, offering a comprehensive analysis for fans of the series.
Recap of the Emerald Witch Arc
Before diving into Episode 12, it’s important to understand the context of the “Emerald Witch Arc.” Ciel Phantomhive and his demonic butler, Sebastian Michaelis, are dispatched to Germany by Queen Victoria to investigate a series of mysterious deaths in the “Werewolves’ Forest”. They soon discover a secluded village, Wolfsschlucht, seemingly trapped in the past and ruled by a young girl named Sieglinde Sullivan, known as the “Emerald Witch”.
The arc explores themes of:
- Illusion vs. Reality: The villagers believe in a curse, but Ciel investigates the scientific truth behind the events.
- Exploitation: Sieglinde is manipulated and confined, her intelligence used for nefarious purposes.
- Redemption: Wolfram, Sieglinde’s guardian, seeks to atone for his past actions.
- War and its Consequences: The arc hints at the brewing tensions between Germany and Great Britain, foreshadowing future conflicts.
Episode 12: Key Events and Analysis
Episode 12, titled “His Butler, Calling,” focuses on several key plotlines:
1. Sieglinde’s Transformation
- Newfound Freedom: Sieglinde arrives in England with Wolfram, seeking a new life free from manipulation and confinement.
- Haircut Scene: A significant scene depicts Sieglinde getting a haircut, symbolizing her shedding of her past identity as the “Emerald Witch” and embracing a new chapter.
- Wardrobe Change: Ciel and Sebastian escort Sieglinde and Wolfram to a tailor (though some argue it should have been a modiste) to acquire suitable attire for meeting the Queen. This highlights the societal expectations and adjustments Sieglinde must navigate in her new environment.
2. Unveiling Grim Reaper Lore
- Sascha and Ludger’s Revelation: The episode delves into the backstory of Grim Reapers, revealing that they are individuals who committed suicide and are now tasked with the grim duty of reaping souls as punishment.
- Sascha’s Perspective: Sascha finds enjoyment in observing how people die and how events subvert expectations, showcasing a detached perspective on human life and death.
- Grim Reaper Interest in Sieglinde: Sascha possesses Sieglinde and Wolfram’s files, implying they were originally intended to die, but their fates were altered.
3. Undertaker’s Cryptic Remarks
- Diedrich’s Encounter: Diedrich reveals that Undertaker visited him during the investigation.
- Undertaker’s Words: Undertaker makes cryptic remarks about the Earls of Phantomhive, noting that Ciel’s father was “all burnt up” and unresurrectable, while also mentioning “the other Earl Phantomhive”. This hints at a deeper mystery surrounding the Phantomhive family lineage.
- Implications: These comments pique Ciel’s interest and suggest the possibility of a twin or another heir, adding a layer of intrigue to the overarching storyline.
4. War and Sebastian’s Nature
- Impending War: The Grim Reapers predict a war between England and Germany, suggesting that Ciel and Sebastian’s actions only delayed the inevitable conflict.
- Sebastian’s Detachment: Sascha believes Sebastian shares a similar detachment from human suffering, hinting at his demonic nature and ulterior motives.
- Sebastian’s Care for Ciel: Despite his demonic nature, Sebastian displays moments of genuine care for Ciel, creating a complex dynamic between the two.
Analysis and Themes
Episode 12 serves as a bridge between the “Emerald Witch Arc” and future storylines, highlighting several key themes:
- The Nature of Good and Evil: The episode explores the complexities of characters like Sebastian and Sascha, who operate outside conventional morality.
- The Weight of the Past: Sieglinde’s transformation and Undertaker’s remarks emphasize how the past continues to influence the present.
- The Inevitability of Conflict: The foreshadowing of war suggests that Ciel’s efforts to maintain peace are ultimately futile.
Fan Theories and Speculations
Episode 12 has sparked numerous fan theories and speculations:
- The “Other Earl Phantomhive”: Who is the other Earl Phantomhive mentioned by Undertaker? Is it a twin, a resurrected Vincent Phantomhive, or someone else entirely?
- Undertaker’s Motives: What is Undertaker’s connection to the Phantomhive family, and what are his ultimate goals?
- The Coming War: How will the impending war between England and Germany impact Ciel and Sebastian’s mission?
Overall Impression
“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” Episode 12 is a compelling installment that effectively wraps up the arc while simultaneously introducing new mysteries and conflicts. The episode’s exploration of Grim Reaper lore, Undertaker’s cryptic remarks, and the looming threat of war creates a sense of anticipation for future episodes.
While some viewers found the episode to be slower-paced, it provides valuable insight into the characters and themes of Black Butler. The episode’s focus on character development and world-building makes it a worthwhile watch for fans of the series.
