Episode 10 of the “Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc,” titled “His Butler, Mopping Up,” sees Ciel and Sebastian continuing their investigation into the mysterious events surrounding the village of Wolfsschlucht and the enigmatic Emerald Witch, Sieglinde Sullivan. This episode, while seemingly transitional, unveils crucial plot elements and introduces new characters, setting the stage for the arc’s climax.
Recap and Initial Impressions
Several reviews note that the episode starts with an extensive recap, eating into the runtime and leaving less room for new plot developments. Despite this, “His Butler, Mopping Up” manages to deliver some significant moments, primarily focusing on Sebastian’s resourcefulness and the introduction of Sascha and Ludger, two Grim Reapers.
Key Events and Developments
Ciel’s Predicament and Diederich’s Intervention
The episode sees Ciel still grappling with the aftereffects of the forest’s miasma and the psychological trauma it induced. He relies heavily on Sebastian for support. During a perilous situation, Ciel is saved by Diederich, adding another layer to the already complex web of alliances and enmities.
The Tank’s Introduction and Swift Demise
A significant portion of the episode revolves around the introduction of a tank, a technologically advanced weapon seemingly out of place in the Victorian era setting. The tank, developed by Frau Sullivan and the German army, is quickly destroyed by Sebastian. This event raises questions about the intentions of the German military and Frau Sullivan’s role in the larger scheme of things.
Wolfram’s Revelation and Departure
Wolfram, Sieglinde’s loyal protector, experiences a crisis of conscience in this episode. He realizes that the army, possibly including Frau Sullivan, never intended for Sieglinde to survive. This revelation shatters his worldview and prompts him to abandon his post in search of Sieglinde, highlighting his unwavering dedication to her. His departure signifies a potential shift in loyalties and adds a layer of uncertainty to Sieglinde’s future.
Sebastian’s Devilish Best
Throughout the episode, Sebastian showcases his exceptional abilities and unwavering loyalty to Ciel. He effortlessly juggles caring for Ciel’s well-being with dismantling advanced weaponry, reaffirming his status as the quintessential demon butler. His actions in this episode underscore his protective nature and his willingness to go to any length to safeguard his master.
Introduction of Sascha and Ludger
The episode concludes with the introduction of Sascha and Ludger, two Grim Reapers tasked with tallying the dead. Their appearance adds a supernatural element to the narrative and suggests a growing concern within the Grim Reaper society regarding the events unfolding in Wolfsschlucht. Notably, they only mark Anne as definitively dead, despite the tank’s destruction, hinting that other characters might have survived.
Themes and Symbolism
Fairy Tales and Narrative Directives
One interpretation of the episode draws parallels between Sebastian’s actions and the fairy tale “Hansel and Gretel.” Sebastian’s destruction of the tank, which he refers to as an “oven,” is seen as a symbolic act of Gretel pushing the witch into her own oven. This interpretation reinforces the idea of Anne and the other “witches” facing a narrative-driven demise.
History and Invention
The presence of advanced technology like the tank raises questions about the historical accuracy of the “Black Butler” universe. However, the narrative seems to suggest that the Germans invented these weapons prematurely, only to later reinvent them for World War I. This approach allows the series to play with historical elements while maintaining its own unique timeline.
Loyalty and Protection
The theme of loyalty is prominently displayed through Wolfram’s actions. His unwavering dedication to Sieglinde and his willingness to abandon his duty to protect her from her own people underscore the strength of their bond. He is portrayed as a loyal hound protecting his mistress from wolves and witches, willing to risk everything for her safety.
Questions and Loose Ends
The Fate of the Tank’s Occupants
Despite the destruction of the tank, the fate of its occupants, besides Anne, remains ambiguous. The Grim Reapers only marking Anne as definitively dead suggests that others might have survived, leaving room for potential reappearances or further plot twists.
Sascha and Ludger’s Role
The introduction of Sascha and Ludger raises questions about their future involvement in the arc. Their purpose is not yet clear, but their presence indicates a growing interest from the Grim Reaper society in the events of Wolfsschlucht.
Wolfram’s Survival
Wolfram’s departure from Wolfsschlucht leaves his fate uncertain. While his survival is not guaranteed, the narrative hints that he might play a crucial role in Sieglinde’s future.
Overall Significance
While some reviews criticize the episode’s pacing and reliance on recaps, “His Butler, Mopping Up” serves as a crucial transitional episode in the “Emerald Witch Arc.” It sets the stage for the arc’s climax by introducing new characters, revealing key plot points, and raising important questions about the motivations and allegiances of various players. The episode underscores the themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and the blurred lines between good and evil, leaving viewers eagerly anticipating the next installment.
The episode functions to prepare the audience for the final act of the Emerald Witch Arc, setting up the conflicts and resolutions to come. The pacing may be slower, but the pieces are moved into place for the final confrontation.
